seo marketing 7 min read

The Ultimate Guide to Getting More Google Reviews

Google reviews can make or break your local business. Learn proven strategies to get more 5-star reviews consistently.

SM
Sarah Mitchell
SEO Specialist
Published February 11, 2024
Featured Image


Why Google Reviews Matter

Google reviews are one of the most powerful tools for local businesses. They:

  • Influence 93% of consumers' purchasing decisions

  • Directly impact your local search ranking

  • Build trust before customers even contact you

  • Provide free marketing through word-of-mouth
  • The Psychology of Reviews

    Understanding why people leave reviews helps you get more of them:

    People leave reviews when:

  • They have an exceptionally good experience

  • They have an exceptionally bad experience

  • Someone asks them to

  • It's easy to do
  • Your job is to create great experiences and make reviewing simple.

    Strategy #1: Ask at the Right Moment

    Timing is everything. The best time to ask for a review is at the "peak of happiness"—right after you've delivered great results.

    For service businesses:

  • Right after completing a successful job

  • When a customer compliments your work

  • After resolving an issue satisfactorily
  • Don't ask:

  • Before the job is done

  • When there are unresolved issues

  • Months after the service
  • Strategy #2: Make It Incredibly Easy

    Every extra step loses customers. Create a direct link to your Google review page:

    1. Search for your business on Google
    2. Click "Write a review"
    3. Copy the URL
    4. Use a URL shortener for easy sharing

    Then share this link via:

  • Text message

  • Email follow-up

  • QR code on receipts

  • Your website
  • Strategy #3: The Follow-Up System

    Don't rely on one ask. Create a system:

    Day 1: Thank the customer, deliver great service
    Day 2: Send a thank-you text/email with review link
    Day 7: If no review, send a gentle reminder
    Day 14: Final follow-up for non-responders

    Strategy #4: Train Your Team

    Everyone who interacts with customers should know how to ask for reviews. Give them scripts:

    "We really appreciate your business! If you have a moment, a Google review would mean the world to us. I can text you the link right now—it only takes 30 seconds."

    Strategy #5: Respond to Every Review

    This serves multiple purposes:

  • Shows you care about customer feedback

  • Encourages others to leave reviews

  • Helps with SEO

  • Turns negative situations into positive outcomes
  • For positive reviews:

  • Thank them specifically

  • Mention something personal from their experience

  • Invite them back
  • For negative reviews:

  • Respond quickly (within 24 hours)

  • Apologize sincerely

  • Take the conversation offline

  • Follow up after resolution
  • What NOT to Do

    Never:

  • Offer incentives for reviews (against Google's TOS)

  • Buy fake reviews

  • Review your own business

  • Ask only happy customers (this is selective solicitation)
  • These practices can get your reviews removed or your listing penalized.

    Handling Negative Reviews

    Negative reviews aren't the end of the world. In fact, businesses with 4.5 stars often convert better than those with 5 stars (it looks more authentic).

    When you get a negative review:
    1. Take a breath—don't respond emotionally
    2. Investigate what happened
    3. Respond professionally and empathetically
    4. Offer to make it right
    5. Follow up privately

    Review Response Templates

    For 5-star reviews:

    "Thank you so much, [Name]! We loved working on your [project type] and are thrilled you're happy with the results. We look forward to serving you again!"

    For negative reviews:

    "Hi [Name], thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear about your experience and take this seriously. Please reach out to us at [phone/email] so we can make this right."

    Tracking Your Progress

    Monitor these metrics monthly:

  • Total review count

  • Average star rating

  • Review velocity (reviews per month)

  • Response rate and time
  • The Compound Effect

    Reviews build on themselves. More reviews → higher rankings → more visibility → more customers → more reviews. Get the flywheel spinning and it becomes self-sustaining.

    Quick Start Action Plan

    This week:
    1. Create your direct Google review link
    2. Ask your 5 most recent happy customers for reviews
    3. Respond to all existing reviews
    4. Set up a follow-up system

    Need help managing your online reputation? SmartWebsites includes automated review request features. Learn more.

    Tags: Google reviews reputation management customer reviews local business
    Share this article
    SM
    Written by

    Sarah Mitchell

    SEO Specialist

    Helping local businesses grow through smart digital marketing and modern web solutions.

    Ready to Grow Your Business Online?

    Get a SmartWebsite that generates leads while you sleep.

    No contracts. Cancel anytime. 30-day trial included.